By the time Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) wrote to the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Administrator David Keeling on October 28, 2026, the agency had already been warned by physicians, nurses, industrial hygienists, construction unions, and employers about OSHA's proposal to roll back certain requirements for the use of respirators in industrial settings.
The lawmakers' letter gathered those objections into a challenge. OSHA, they claimed, was proposing to remove safeguards without first establishing that workers would be equally protected without them.
“To date, OSHA has been unable to collect the evidence it needs to justify its proposals and finalize these rules,” Warren, Omar, and more than two dozen congressional colleagues wrote.
Behind that dispute lies a sequence of decisions familiar to anyone responsible for protecting workers from airborne chemicals. An employer must determine whether an exposure can be eliminated or controlled and barring that, when a respirator or other form of personal protective equipment (PPE) becomes necessary, which equipment will work under certain conditions, and whether the person wearing it can safely do the job.
“PPE is the last line in the hierarchy of controls,” safety consultant Carl Heinlein told 3E. His advice to clients is always to address hazards as high in that hierarchy as possible, reducing exposure at its source before relying on a respirator as the final barrier.
It is the requirements governing how to manage respiratory protection programs that OSHA has proposed easing. One initiative would eliminate mandatory medical evaluations for workers using filtering facepiece respirators, including N95s, as well as loose-fitting powered air-purifying respirators (PAPRs). Another would revise respiratory protection provisions across 16 chemical standards, giving employers greater latitude in some equipment choices and greater reliance on the agency's general Respiratory Protection standard.
Dispute Over Medical Evaluations
The medical evaluation proposal, published July 1, 2025, would waive mandatory medical examinations for workers who use filtering facepiece respirators, including N95s and PAPRs. Evaluations would be required for other respirator types.
Under the existing standard, a physician or other licensed health care professional assesses whether an employee can safely use a respirator. The process can begin with a questionnaire; it does not necessarily require an in-person examination.
OSHA has argued that this step is simply unnecessary. The available data, the agency claimed in the Federal Register, are “insufficient to establish that medical evaluations meaningfully reduce material impairment” caused by wearing them.
Warren and Omar's letter disputes the case for proceeding on that basis. It also cites concerns that employers could confuse the removal of medical evaluations with changes to separate fit-testing obligations, weakening programs beyond the proposal's intended scope.
Some argue this is fundamentally a clinical debate. As such, occupational physician Robert McLellan, a past president of the American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine (ACOEM), weighed in. In submitted testimony for OSHA's August 19, 2026, hearing, McLellan argued that passing rates alone do not capture the evaluations' value.
“Medical evaluations identify risks and guide safe accommodations, even when clearance is granted,” he wrote on ACOEM's behalf. Those accommodations can include a different respirator, limits on duration of use, or changes in working conditions.
OSHA's own guidance explains why the job matters. In an Auguust 1, 2025, interpretation letter to McLellan and occupational medicine researcher Philip Harber, the agency said evaluations ensure workers “can tolerate the physiological burden associated with such use.” It included equipment weight, musculoskeletal stress, and “limitations on auditory, visual, and odor sensations” among relevant considerations. Employers, said OSHA, must provide clinicians with information on exertion, duration of use, other protective equipment, and temperature and humidity extremes. The interpretation addresses current requirements; it does not decide whether every respirator category should retain screening.
Room to Improve Screening
Some critics want OSHA to improve medical screening, rather than eliminate it.
Harber, an adjunct professor of public health at the University of Arizona, favors changes that would improve effectiveness and reduce the burden of respiratory protection management while preserving access to professional evaluation.
“The proposed change should not be approved as written,” Harber told 3E. “However, there is little evidence that the current approach, in which most workers receive only an outdated questionnaire, is effective in predicting who will encounter difficulty.”
He suggested concentrating clinical attention on workers who identify concerns, supported by mandatory written notices explaining how to obtain an evaluation from an occupational health professional familiar with the workplace and respirators.
“I suggest considering changing emphasis from a minimal evaluation for all users to facilitating high-quality evaluations for the small proportion of workers who perceive potential concerns after starting using the device,” he said.
Harber would retain mandatory evaluations for all users when a PAPR is used in a higher risk situation. McLellan's testimony, on the other hand, supported retaining current requirements while pursuing targeted revisions, research, and wider use of online and automated questionnaire review.
What Changes Across the Chemical Standards
OSHA's second proposed rollback concerns equipment selection and chemical-specific instructions. The affected standards cover substances including asbestos, benzene, cadmium, ethylene oxide, formaldehyde, inorganic arsenic, lead, methylene chloride, vinyl chloride, and 1,3-butadiene.
The amendments would have different effects under different standards. Some remove particular equipment restrictions; others replace chemical-specific provisions with references to OSHA's general Respiratory Protection standard.
In its benzene proposal, for instance, OSHA said revisions would provide employers with “greater flexibility in the respirators they select for exposed workers, while providing equivalent worker protection.” It would remove particular cartridge and canister restrictions and replace certain provisions specifying when respirators are required, in accordance with the general standard.
The lead proposal illustrates a different change. Where lead aerosols may irritate the eyes or skin, OSHA would allow half-mask respirators with appropriate eye and face protection instead of requiring full-facepiece respirators. The agency also proposes removing lead's explicit high-efficiency particulate air filter requirement.
The Associated General Contractors of America has opposed the proposed lead respirator substitution. The American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA), too, has urged OSHA to retain high-efficiency filter requirements for lead, asbestos, cadmium, and inorganic arsenic. In its November 1, 2025, comments, AIHA warned that “simplification must not compromise safety or shift interpretive burdens onto employers and consultants.” It requested an explicit mapping between existing safeguards and acceptable equivalents under the general standard.
“It Happens All the Time!”
Those implementation questions are the stuff of Carl Heinlein's everyday work and color the debate significantly. The regulations, after all, exist for the workers who wear the respirators, and Heinlein, whose shopfloor experience as an industrial hygienist is extensive, takes a practical view.
“PPE is the last line in the hierarchy of controls,” he reiterated to 3E. “If we can eliminate the hazard, if we can use administrative controls, we do … It's the last line of defense.”
Asked how often respirator misuse causes problems in industrial settings, Heinlein laughed: “It happens all the time!” He pointed to the importance (and employer responsibility) of selection, fit, training, cleaning, maintenance, and storage.
Providing a respirator, in his account, does not by itself establish that a worker is protected. A well-chosen, well-fitting respirator thrown into the bed of a truck on a hot day, he said, can end up as useless as no respirator at all.
“If you're going to remove a requirement, why?” Heinlein asked hypothetically. “Is the hazard abated? Has science changed what the exposures are? Just because you put a respirator on doesn't mean you're wearing it properly.”
“You can wear a helmet with no chin strap. You can drive a car without a seat belt,” noted Heinlein, “but should you?”
Related Resources
News
News
News
News